weird.stats

For the incurably curious.

Sentenced to die.

4.1%

estimated to have been
wrongfully convicted.

U.S. defendants sentenced to death, 1973–2004.
A 2014 study’s estimate—not a count of innocent people executed.

Gross, O’Brien, Hu & Kennedy · PNAS, 2014

How certain is that number?

An estimate has edges.

The model’s 95% confidence interval is 2.8–5.2%. It does not capture every uncertainty about the assumptions or about who was innocent.

Estimated exoneration rate under continued threat of execution On a zero to six percent scale, the estimate is 4.1 percent and the 95 percent confidence interval runs from 2.8 to 5.2 percent. 4.1%2.8%5.2%06%
Point estimate and 95% confidence interval · scale 0–6%

Innocence doesn’t
unlock the door.

41 of 1,000

sentences illustrated in pale light · 4.1% estimate

An imagined prison cell, then 1,000 illustrated death sentences. At the study’s estimate, 41 represent wrongful convictions. Pale light shows that proportion—not identified people. Unlit cells do not establish guilt. These are not actual cells or a count of executions.

Off death row.
Still not free.

A reduced sentence can end the threat of execution without clearing someone’s name. The researchers found that exoneration became much less likely after that threat ended.

They modeled what might be uncovered if everyone remained under the intense scrutiny associated with a death sentence. That is how they reached 4.1%—which they considered a conservative estimate of wrongful convictions.

Escaping execution can still mean
spending your life in prison.

The study, the assumptions, the numbers

The study followed 7,482 defendants. Its Kaplan–Meier model estimated exoneration under continued execution threat at 21.4 years after conviction. It accounts for different observation times and departures from death row.

Exoneration is an imperfect proxy for innocence. Departures may be related to innocence, too. The authors examined those assumptions in sensitivity analyses. Their “at least” interpretation is not a statistical lower bound. This result does not describe today’s death row or all criminal convictions.

Values in the graphic · U.S. death sentences, 1973–2004
MeasurePercent
Model estimate4.1
95% interval, lower end2.8
95% interval, upper end5.2
Download the numbers (CSV)

Source: Gross et al., Rate of false conviction of criminal defendants who are sentenced to death. PNAS 111(20), 7230–7235 (2014). Figure 2; Analysis, Sensitivity analysis, and Discussion. These links refer to the same study.

Historical research · Sources checked October 5, 2026

Open this discovery